As Christmas gets closer, one thing many people in the UK look forward to is the release of the latest John Lewis Christmas advert. Whether it appears on television or pops up on social media, it often becomes a talking point, with viewers discussing their favourite moments or sharing their reactions online.
For some people, these adverts are heartwarming and capture the spirit of Christmas through themes of kindness, family and giving. Others, however, may see them as clever marketing campaigns designed to encourage spending during the festive season. This raises an interesting question: can one advert really have the same meaning for everyone?
This is where Stuart Hall’s Encoding and Decoding Theory becomes useful. Hall argued that media messages are not simply accepted by audiences. Instead, people interpret media in different ways depending on their own experiences, values and beliefs. By looking at the John Lewis Christmas adverts through this theory, we can explore how the same message can lead to very different reactions from different audiences.

So, What Does Encoding and Decoding Mean?
Hall (1980) suggested that media producers create content with a particular message in mind. This is known as encoding. However, audiences do not always interpret that message in the same way. The process of making sense of a media message is called decoding.
Think about the last Christmas advert you watched. Did it make you emotional? Did you think it was heartwarming? Or did you immediately recognise it as a marketing campaign? Even though everyone is watching the same advert, people can walk away with completely different opinions.
Hall argued that audiences generally respond in three ways: dominant, negotiated and oppositional readings.
A Closer Look at John Lewis Christmas Advert- Where Love Lives ( 2025)
A recent example of a John Lewis Christmas advert is Where Love Lives (2025). The advert tells the story of a father and son who seem to have drifted apart over time. On Christmas Day, the father receives a vinyl record as a gift. As he plays the record, he is transported back to memories of his youth and finds himself reconnecting with his son through music. Throughout the advert, viewers see the growing distance between the two generations slowly disappear as they share a meaningful moment together. By the end of the advert, the message focuses on love, connection and the importance of expressing feelings to the people who matter most.




This advert is a good example of Stuart Hall’s Encoding and Decoding Theory because, although John Lewis presents a clear message about family and connection, audiences may interpret that message in different ways.
Someone taking a dominant reading is likely to accept the advert’s message as intended. They may find the story touching and appreciate the values of generosity and togetherness being presented.
A negotiated reading might come from a viewer who enjoys the advert and understands its positive message but also recognises that it is part of a wider marketing strategy. They appreciate the storytelling while remaining aware that the company is promoting its brand.
An oppositional reading could be taken by someone who rejects the emotional message altogether. Instead of seeing a heartwarming Christmas story, they may view the advert as a way of encouraging consumers to spend money during the festive season.
Why Is This Important?
What’s interesting about these different reactions is that they show audiences are not passive. We do not simply accept media messages exactly as creators intend. Instead, our own experiences, beliefs and values shape the way we understand and respond to media content.
For example, someone who enjoys Christmas traditions may connect emotionally with a John Lewis advert, while someone who is more sceptical of advertising may focus on its commercial purpose. Even though both people are watching the same advert, they can walk away with completely different interpretations.
John Lewis Christmas adverts are a great example of Stuart Hall’s Encoding and Decoding Theory in action. While the adverts are created with a clear message about family, love and togetherness, audiences are free to interpret that message in their own way. Whether viewers see them as heartwarming stories, clever marketing campaigns, or a combination of both, it is clear that media messages do not have one fixed meaning. Instead, meaning is created through the interaction between the media and its audience.
References :
Hall, S. (1980) ‘Encoding/decoding’, in Hall, S., Hobson, D., Lowe, A. and Willis, P. (eds.) Culture, Media, Language: Working Papers in Cultural Studies, 1972-79. London: Hutchinson, pp. 128-138.
John Lewis Partnership (2025) Where Love Lives | John Lewis & Partners | Christmas Ad 2025. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1bRlnyQeDk (Accessed: 11 October 2026).
John Lewis Partnership (2026) Every John Lewis Christmas Advert Aired. Available at: https://www.johnlewis.com/content/gifts/every-john-lewis-christmas-advert-ever-aired (Accessed: 11 October 2026).



